Documents & Evidence Library

All Supporting Documentation for Carroun Road Case

Document Collection Overview

170+
Emails Analyzed
3
Wright Hassall Letters
8
Insurance Documents
5
Land Registry Docs

Quick Navigation

Wright Hassall Letters (URGENT) Lease & Title Docs Tribunal Prep Roof Repair Evidence Insurance Email Timelines

HCR Wright Hassall Letters (URGENT - COURT PROCEEDINGS THREATENED)

Letters from opposing solicitor representing Mr Al Sarpong. Latest letter (9 Jan 2026) threatens court proceedings within 14 days.

View Full Wright Hassall Timeline & Analysis

CRITICAL EVIDENCE DISCOVERIES - Key Defence Points

Recently discovered evidence that significantly strengthens KG Project's defence against Wright Hassall's claims.

Evidence Discovery #1: The March 2021 "Notification" Myth

Wright Hassall Claim: KG Project "was notified of roof issues in March 2021" and failed to act - suggesting landlord neglect over 11 months before the 2022 repairs.

THE ACTUAL EVIDENCE (Emails 31 March - 1 April 2021):

Al's email (31 March 2021):

"My only immediate concern would be the roof - there was a leak during a heavy bout of rain back in October. It has not happened since then... Is the roof solely my responsibility or does it come under the coverage of the freehold?"

Katerina's response (1 April 2021):

"In regards of roof renovation issue I have to look into Lease Agreement and get back to you shortly."

WHY THIS DESTROYS WH's ARGUMENT:

  • The leak Al mentioned was from October 2020 - 5 months before the email
  • Al explicitly stated "It has not happened since then" - the leak had STOPPED
  • Al was asking an informational question, not demanding urgent repairs
  • Al himself said renovation works should wait until "next year" (2022)
  • Katerina acknowledged and said she'd check the lease - reasonable for a non-emergency
  • The March 2022 repairs were for a NEW, DIFFERENT leak - confirmed by Al's 29 Jan 2023 email: "nearly a year since the leak first occurred"
View Full Email Analysis View Counter-Argument in WH Timeline

Evidence Discovery #2: The Two Different Leaks

The documentary evidence proves there were two separate leak incidents - not one ongoing problem:

Date Event Outcome
October 2020 Single leak during heavy rain Resolved itself - "has not happened since"
31 March 2021 Al asks informational question about roof responsibility Katerina says she'll check lease - no emergency
~Feb 2022 NEW leak - emergency roof works done This is the disputed £3,500
29 Jan 2023 Al says "nearly a year since leak first occurred" Confirms 2022 leak was NEW - not from 2020

Strategic Significance: Wright Hassall cannot claim Katerina ignored a roof problem for 11+ months. The October 2020 leak stopped on its own. The March 2022 emergency was a completely separate incident.

Lease & Title Documents

Official Land Registry documents and lease agreements

Tribunal Preparation Materials

Legal analysis and evidence bundle documents prepared for potential tribunal proceedings

Legal Analysis

Tenant Breach Files

Evidence Bundle

Contractor Legitimacy Evidence

WH Letter Analysis

Roof Trespass & Significant Alteration Evidence

Photographic evidence proving Al Sarpong carried out SIGNIFICANT ROOF ALTERATIONS (not emergency repairs as claimed by Al and Wright Hassall) without freeholder consent - constituting trespass to Retained Parts.

KEY EVIDENCE POINTS:
  • Not Emergency Repairs: Invoice shows planned work costing £3,500 including leadwork repointing, tile replacement, and rubberised coating installation
  • Significant Alteration: Photos show systematic slate replacement across substantial roof area
  • Trespass: Work done on shared Retained Parts without freeholder consent
  • Pre-planned: Work completed Feb 16, 2022 but KG Project only notified March 2, 2022

Invoice & Documentation (Al-Katerina Communication, Sept 2022)

Roof Work Photographs (Al-Stan Communication)

These photos were attached by Al Sarpong in correspondence with Stan Harris showing the extent of roof alterations. Note the clear contrast between old weathered slates and newly laid dark slates.

Evidence Documentation

Original Roof Repairs Folder

Insurance Documents

Building insurance policies for 14-16 Carroun Road

2025 Policy

2026 Policy

Draft Response Letters to Wright Hassall

Draft letters prepared for response to Wright Hassall LLP

Benchmark Solicitors Onboarding

Client care documents from Benchmark Solicitors LLP

Original Email Files (.eml) & Comprehensive Timelines

Raw email files and comprehensive timeline analysis

Email Analysis Complete: All email chains have been thoroughly analyzed and organized into comprehensive timelines:

Raw .eml files location: C:\Users\Kater\Desktop\CARROUN\EMAILS\

Note: Original .eml files can be viewed in any email client (Outlook, Thunderbird) or text editor. Chain emails contain multiple messages that have been extracted into the timelines above.

Pre-Prepared Timelines (PDF)

← Back to Overview View Case Summary →